Introduction. Direct causes of preterm birth include spontaneous unexplained preterm labor with intact membranes (uterine distension, maternal-fetal stress, and intrauterine infections), idiopathic preterm premature rupture of membranes (PROM), delivery prompted by maternal or fetal indications, and multiple pregnancy. Case report. This case report describes a 31-year-old woman at 21 weeks of gestation who presented at the emergency room with vaginal bleeding. She had a history of previous premature birth at 24 weeks and emergency caesarean section for abruptio placentae at 29 weeks. Despite a cervical length of 32 mm, a prophylactic cervical cerclage was performed at 14 weeks due to her history. At 20 weeks, an Arabin pessary was added for cervical shortening to 25 mm with funneling. During examination, the amniotic pouch was seen inside the cervical pessary, and after the removal of the pessary, a 3-cm cervical rupture was observed cranial and right to the cerclage. Attempting another cerclage failed due to a large cervical rupture visible after anesthetic muscular relaxation. The patient chose the expectant management, but later opted for the termination of the pregnancy due to significant bleeding. Conclusions. The peculiarity of this case was that the fetus was evacuated through the cervical rupture, and uterine curettage was performed through the same pathway. The cervix was 2 cm dilated, and the repair was done with separate “X” resorbable sutures. The patient was discharged four days post-procedure, with favorable follow-up.
Keywords
cerclage, pessary, cervical rupture
Rezumat
Introducere. Printre cauzele directe ale naşterii înainte de termen se numără travaliul prematur spontan cu membranele intacte (distensia uterină, stresul materno-fetal şi infecţiile intrauterine), ruptura idiopatică prematură a membranelor, naşterea indicată din motive materne sau fetale şi sarcina multiplă. Prezentare de caz. Acest studiu de caz descrie o pacientă în vârstă de 31 de ani, gravidă, cu sarcină de 21 de săptămâni, care s-a prezentat la camera de gardă pentru sângerare vaginală. Pacienta avea antecedente de naştere prematură anterioară la 24 de săptămâni şi operaţie cezariană de urgenţă pentru dezlipire prematură de placentă normal inserată la 29 de săptămâni. În urma istoricului obstetrical, s-a efectuat un cerclaj cervical profilactic la 14 săptămâni, în condiţiile unei cervicometrii de 32 mm. La 20 de săptămâni, a fost montat un pesar Arabin, din cauza scurtării colului la 25 mm cu funelizare. La momentul prezentării la camera de gardă, s-a observat sacul amniotic în interiorul pesarului cervical. S-a decis internarea pacientei. După îndepărtarea pesarului, s-a observat o ruptură cervicală de 3 cm cranial şi lateral dreapta de zona cerclajului. Încercarea de a efectua un alt cerclaj a eşuat, din cauza unei rupturi cervicale mari vizibile după relaxarea musculară sub anestezie. Pacienta a ales managementul expectativ, dar ulterior şi-a dat consimţământul pentru întreruperea sarcinii, în urma sângerării semnificative. Concluzii. Caracteristica distinctivă a acestui caz a fost evacuarea produsului de concepţie prin ruptura cervicală, iar chiuretajul uterin a fost efectuat prin aceeaşi cale. Colul era dilatat 2 cm, iar închiderea soluţiei de continuitate cervicale s-a făcut cu fire de sutură resorbabile separate, „în X”. Pacienta a fost externată patru zile după procedură, având o evoluţie favorabilă.
Direct causes of preterm birth include spontaneous unexplained preterm labor with intact membranes, idiopathic preterm premature rupture of membranes (PROM), delivery prompted by maternal or fetal indications, and multiple pregnancy. Spontaneous preterm labor rates tend to increase under various circumstances, including uterine distension, which can arise in multifetal pregnancies or cases of hydramnios, wherein an excess of amniotic fluid stretches the uterine walls. Maternal-fetal stress also plays a significant role, as heightened levels of maternal cortisol, often associated with stress, can trigger premature contractions and labor. Additionally, intrauterine infections contribute to the risk of preterm labor, with common microorganisms, such as Gardnerella vaginalis, Mycoplasma hominis and Ureaplasma urealyticum, implicated in inflammatory processes that can prompt early labor onset. These factors collectively underscore the complex interplay of physiological and environmental influences on the timing of childbirth(1).
Case report
This paper represents a case report of a 31-year-old woman, non-smoker, with a normal Body Mass Index (BMI), with 21 weeks of gestation pregnancy, who presented at our emergency room for vaginal bleeding. Her medical history included micropolycystic ovary syndrome and hepatitis B virus infection (undetectable viremia).
Her obstetrical history was impressive. She had a previous vaginal premature birth at 24 weeks of gestation, six years before. The baby did not survive. Two years later, she had an emergency caesarean section for abruptio placentae at 29 weeks of gestation, and the 920-gram baby boy lived, his evolution being uneventful. During that pregnancy, at 23 weeks of gestation, she was diagnosed with short cervix, and an emergency vaginal cervical cerclage was performed.
For the present pregnancy, she followed the national guide of prenatal care during the first trimester of pregnancy. No maternal infections were diagnosed, and the pregnancy had a low risk of genetic disorders at standard first-trimester screening. A prophylactic cervical cerclage was decided to be performed, considering the maternal history, even though the cervix was 32 mm long at the vaginal ultrasound measurement. The cervical cerclage was performed without any maternal complications at 14 weeks of gestations. The patient was also prescribed intravaginal progesterone.
The pregnancy evolution was in normal ranges until 20 weeks of gestation, when funneling was observed for 2.5 cm of the cervix, with opened internal cervical os and closed external cervical os (Figure 1). As an extreme measure, it was decided to be added an Arabin vaginal pessary, which was placed uneventful surrounding the cervical cerclage. For one week, the pregnancy had no problem, until the current emergency presentation for vaginal bleeding.
The present clinical examination revealed the amniotic pouch, easily observed inside the cervical pessary at speculum evaluation, and reduced vaginal bleeding. The abdominal ultrasound identified a 21-week fetus with normal cardiac rhythm, fetal movements, 14 cm amniotic fluid index, and homogenous placentae (Figure 2). The patient was admitted in the obstetric department. In the following 12 hours, the patient received tocolytic therapy, the vaginal bleeding was reduced, and a detailed counseling was performed regarding the therapeutic options.
The removal of the pessary was performed, and there was an impressive clinical identification. The amniotic pouch was visible through an impressive cervical rupture. It was observed a 3-cm rupture on the right lateral cervical side cranial of the cervical cerclage which was in place (Figure 3). We decided to try to perform another vaginal cerclage under anesthesia above the present one. During the procedure, under the anesthetic muscular relaxation, it was observed that the cervical rupture was about 6 cm in diameter, the amniotic pouch could not be reduced, and another cervical cerclage could not be performed. The present cervical cerclage was removed. The cervix was closed. The patient did not accept the idea of abortion, and she wanted an expectative management. The following 12 hours were without any complications, but later an important vaginal bleeding occurred. The patient accepted that the pregnancy was compromised, and she consented for the termination of pregnancy.
The peculiarity is that the fetus was evacuated trough the cervical rupture and, also, the uterine curettage following the abortion was made using the same pathway. The cervix was 2 cm opened. The cervical rupture was repaired after curettage using multiple “X” resorbable sutures (Figure 4). The patient was discharged four days after the procedure, and the follow-up was favorable.
Discussion
The specialty literature does not contain many cases similar to the one presented, with most studies focusing on the role of cervical cerclage and/or cervical pessary in preventing preterm birth.
In a study from 2020 that included 81 patients with singleton pregnancies between 2005 and 2017, the effectiveness of the McDonald cerclage versus the combination of cerclage and Arabin pessary in preventing birth before 34 weeks was evaluated. The results did not show statistically significant differences between the two groups regarding birth before 34 weeks. However, the duration of neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) admission and birth weight were lower and higher, respectively, in the combined group, especially in patients with cervical canal length below the third percentile(2).
A study conducted at our center in 2021, involving 75 patients with cervical insufficiency, who were divided into three study arms (cerclage group, pessary group, and the combined group), revealed that the average gestational age at birth was higher in the combined group (38.33 weeks) compared to the cerclage group (37.82 weeks) and the pessary group (35.73 weeks). Additionally, the separate groups exhibited higher rates of spontaneous abortion compared to the combined group, which did not experience any spontaneous abortion or preterm birth events.
Furthermore, premature rupture of membranes in patients with a shorter cervical canal length was more frequent in the pessary group. These results shed light on the potential benefits of combined interventions in the management of cervical insufficiency, suggesting that they may lead to improved pregnancy outcomes compared to cerclage or pessary alone(3).
A randomized clinical feasibility study, conducted in an open-label manner in 2021, which included 18 patients with singleton pregnancies and risk factors for preterm birth (such as a history of spontaneous preterm birth, preterm premature rupture of membranes before 34 weeks, or cervical surgeries), who agreed to participate, aimed to compare the efficacy of cerclage versus pessary, as well as intravaginal progesterone at a dose of 200 mg. The results indicate that such a study is feasible, but more eligible participants are necessary to draw conclusive findings(4).
A recent study from Germany demonstrates that early interventions (such as cerclage, pessary, progesterone, and combinations thereof) lead to a longer interval between intervention and birth, particularly concerning very low birth weight infants born before 32 weeks. The study included 575 newborns from 424 mothers who underwent interventions between 20 and 25 weeks to prevent preterm birth. The combined intervention group had a higher average gestational age (27 weeks) and a higher average birth weight (980 g) compared to single interventions(5).
A case report from 2021 illustrates the potential complications associated with inserting a pessary in the context of cervical insufficiency and bulging membranes in a twin pregnancy. Despite the availability of various management options, such as vaginal progesterone, cervical cerclage and cervical pessary, determining the most effective treatment strategy remains uncertain, particularly in cases of dilated cervix and exposed membranes in twin pregnancies. In this specific instance, a twin pregnancy at 22+6/7 weeks of gestation was admitted to the hospital due to cervical insufficiency with bulging membranes. Following an unsuccessful attempt at cervical cerclage, an Arabin pessary was inserted without administering antibiotics, given the absence of signs of infection.
Subsequently, caesarean delivery was performed at 24 weeks of gestation due to spontaneous preterm labor and rupture of membranes, with the first baby presenting in a transverse lie position. Tragically, the first twin was stillborn, with the Arabin pessary found adherent to the fetal head, contributing to funisitis/sepsis and mechanical insult. The second baby was born alive. The subsequent investigations suggested that the adherence of the pessary to the fetal head led to the demise of the first twin.
This case underscores the importance of carefully evaluating the antibiotic treatment in cases of bulging membranes and dilated cervix, even in the absence of signs or symptoms of infection. Furthermore, it suggests caution in pessary insertion, especially during the second trimester, due to the risk of dislocation within the uterus during contractions and the potential harm to extremely preterm fetuses. Such insights contribute to the ongoing discussion surrounding the management of cervical insufficiency in twin pregnancies, emphasizing the need for individualized approaches and careful consideration of potential risks and benefits(6).
Another case report from 2021 highlights a severe ischemic gangrene of the scalp in an extremely preterm infant born at 24+5/7 weeks of gestation and admitted to the neonatal intensive care unit following a caesarean section due to maternal chorioamnionitis. Notably, an Arabin pessary had been inserted in addition to a previous cervical cerclage due to cervical insufficiency at 21+5/7 weeks of pregnancy. Subsequently, at 23+5/7 weeks of pregnancy, preterm rupture of membranes occurred, and both devices were retained to support fetal viability.
At 24+4/7 weeks of pregnancy, the mother developed maternal chorioamnionitis, prompting an urgent caesarean section. Transvaginal manual manipulation was necessary during the procedure. Upon admission to the NICU, the infant presented severe shock, requiring high-dose vasopressors and blood products. Following the surgical repair, a bilateral grade IV intracranial hemorrhage was observed. Subsequently, the decision was made to withdraw the life support.
It is speculated that maternal chorioamnionitis and local infection may have acted as predisposing factors, with the presence of the pessary potentially contributing to uterine contractions and its manipulation during the procedure acting as a precipitating factor. This case underscores the importance of carefully considering the risks and benefits of interventions such as pessary insertion, particularly in the context of preterm labor and maternal complications like chorioamnionitis(7).
In a retrospective population-based cohort study conducted in Ohio from 2006 to 2015, involving 1,428,655 singleton and twin live births, the researchers evaluated the association between cerclage use during pregnancy and severe maternal morbidity. The study revealed that more than one in ten women who underwent cerclage experienced adverse maternal outcomes. Even after adjusting for factors such as gestational age at delivery, the risk of serious adverse events remained more than twofold higher for pregnancies with cerclage compared to those without. Among the individual adverse outcomes observed in the cerclage group, chorioamnionitis, unplanned operation after delivery, and maternal hospital transfer were the most common, affecting 4.4%, 4.2% and 3.4% of pregnancies, respectively. Less common adverse events included unplanned hysterectomy, uterine rupture, blood transfusion, and maternal ICU admission, with lower frequencies observed in both groups(8).
Conclusions
Although a recommended and proven method for preventing preterm birth, the use of cerclage with or without the Arabin pessary can lead to unfavorable consequences, both for pregnancy viability and maternal obstetric future. The present case is rare but worth mentioning, as not many articles in the specialty literature address the negative aspects associated with the use of cerclage and cervical pessary. A particularly notable aspect in this case is the patient’s obstetric history, which places her at an increased risk for spontaneous abortion or preterm birth, prompting the cerclage to be performed under conditions of a long cervical canal at 14 weeks of pregnancy. Additionally, medical and psychological counseling for patients facing such a diagnosis is crucial, as severe maternal complications, such as uterine rupture and emergency hysterectomy, can threaten not only the woman’s obstetric future, but also her life.
Autori pentru corespondenţă: Romina-Marina Sima E-mail: romina.sima@umfcd.ro
CONFLICT OF INTEREST: none declared.
FINANCIAL SUPPORT: none declared.
This work is permanently accessible online free of charge and published under the CC-BY.
Bibliografie
Cunningham FLK, Bloom Sea, editors. Preterm Labor. In: Williams Obstetrics. 24th Ed. Mc Graw Hill Education; 2014:829-61.
Wolnicki BG, von Wedel F, Mouzakiti N, et al. Combined treatment of McDonald cerclage and Arabin-pessary: a chance in the prevention of spontaneous preterm birth? J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2020;33(19):3249-57.
Pleş L, Sima RM, Ricu A, Moga MA, Ionescu AC. The efficacy of cervical cerclage combined with a pessary for the prevention of spontaneous preterm birth.
J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2021;34(15):2535-9.
Care A, Jackson R, O’Brien E, et al. Cervical cerclage, pessary, or vaginal progesterone in high-risk pregnant women with short cervix: a randomized feasibility study. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2021;34(1):49-57.
Hanke K, Fortmann MI, Auerswald GH, et al. Use and impact of pessary, cerclage, and progesterone for the secondary prevention of preterm birth: Data from the German Neonatal Network. Z Geburtshilfe Neonatol. 2024. Published online: January 16, 2024. doi:10.1055/a-2217-9463.
Monari F, Salerno C, Torcetta F, Po’ G, Facchinetti F. Intrapartum stillbirth for sepsis complicating Arabin cervical pessary placement in a twin pregnancy. Minerva Obstet Gynecol. 2021;73(3):384-7.
Pérez-Iranzo A, Olaya Alamar V, Mira Ferrer LM, Nos Colom A. Severe ischaemic gangrene of scalp in an extreme preterm: a fatal case of combined aetiology. BMJ Case Rep. 2021;14(1):e236375.
Lee M, Rossi RM, DeFranco EA. Severe maternal morbidity associated with cerclage use in pregnancy. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2022;35(25):5957-63.